[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
[FYI] Matthew Skala: "I have made my point and don't need the headaches"
- To: debate@fitug.de
- Subject: [FYI] Matthew Skala: "I have made my point and don't need the headaches"
- From: "Axel H Horns" <horns@t-online.de>
- Date: Tue, 28 Mar 2000 09:47:27 +0100
- Comment: This message comes from the debate mailing list.
- Organization: PA Axel H Horns
- Reply-to: horns@t-online.de
- Sender: owner-debate@fitug.de
[Wer laesst sich schon gerne von einer finanziellen Uebermacht vor
Gericht in die Pfanne hauen? Die Reaktion von Matthew Skala auf das
Vergleichsangebot duerfte ueberaus verstaendlich sein. Aber doch
bleibt es schade, dass die FUD-Strategie von CP hier offenbar voll
durchgeschlagen hat. Dabei waere es hoechst interessant gewesen, mal
juristisch bis zum Ende zu gehen. Auch in Sachen DeCSS mehren sich
die Vergleichsnachrichten. Ein guter Resonanzboden fuer weitere FUD-
Attacks von pekuniaer gutgestellten Unternehmen, laestige Dateien aus
dem Netz zu kippen. ---AHH]
http://cryptome.org/skala.htm
----------------------------- CUT -----------------------------------
27 March 2000. Matthew Skala confirms this statement is his. Thanks
also to anonymous.
http://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=00/03/27/1736221&cid=101
Yes, I settled (Score:5, Informative)
by Anonymous Coward on Monday March 27, @06:03PM CST (#101)
I have no Slashdot account, cope.
Yes, late Friday I made an agreement with the plaintiffs settling the
cases in Boston and Vancouver out of court. I was planning to wait
until I heard the results of today's hearing before making any
announcement, but it sounds like that is now. I don't know Eddy's
current status; last I heard from him he had not officially settled
but was close to doing so.
I settled because I have made my point and don't need the headaches.
I don't think it's appropriate to characterise this as Microsystems
et al "winning". The document is out there, I know the mirror sites
aren't going to take it down without a fight (even with my copyright
assignment), and judging by the level of conspiracy theory here on
Slashdot, the companies' public relations nightmares have only just
begun.
Whatever public face they may put on their press releases, I don't
think the plaintiffs are very happy right now. Whether they end up
happy or having the last laugh will really depend upon how you, the
public, reacts to this situation, and that's out of my hands.
There are serious jurisdiction issues for the Boston lawsuit, but the
Vancouver lawsuit against me was certainly for real, and many of the
relevant legal questions have not yet been decided in Canada. So I'd
be faced with being a test case, and all the "fun" that involves. My
right to do what I did may appear cut-and-dried to Slashdotters, but
we'd have to educate the judge about that, and face all the
litigation tricks that a well-funded multinational corporation can
come up with. Litigation always involves a risk no matter how good
one's case may appear at the outset. I'm a mathematician, not a
gambler. I've got better ways to spend my time, thank you all so very
much.
Yes, it would be more satisfying to walk away with a court decision
saying, "Matthew, you didn't do anything bad, you're a good boy", but
enough other people have told me that that it's not worth the hassle
to try to get it from a court as well. I reached the point of
diminishing returns. If you think that makes me a coward or a sell-
out, feel free to prove yourself a better hacker than me by doing
yourself whatever you think I ought to have done.
I'm sorry for the people who may find their situations worsened by my
having made the copyright assignment. I still think that the overall
effect of my actions has been positive. You might well want to
explore the fact that the original documents gave permission to
redistribute.
- Matthew Skala
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
PGP Key & x.509 certificate:
http://137.216.191.250/keys.html
----------------------------- CUT -----------------------------------