Abel Wisman wrote:
I will not accept that. You are not the chair, so a motion put forth by you cannot be recognized by you. Please wait your turn. In any case, as i've said already, there will be no voting on any motions by the panel until it's members have been verified by the Provisional Membership Committee.
-----Original Message-----
From: panel-admin@mailman.icannatlarge.org [mailto:panel-admin@mailman.icannatlarge.org] On Behalf Of Sotiris Sotiropoulos
Sent: 04 June 2003 22:45
To: panel@mailman.icannatlarge.org
Subject: Re: [Panel] Proposal for agenda
I have a real problem with this motion. 1) I do not think it's necessary to appoint a chair of the verification committee, it can rotate just as on the panel.
Your thoughts are duly noted, however the motion was tabled and seconded so a vote will determine the outcome of that.
A proposal and an appointment are two very different things. The membership will elect the Membership Committee just as they elected the Panel. If you have a problem with that, I suggest you take it to the Membership as a whole.
2) I don't think it's the membership's wish that the Panel appoint any Chairs of any committees
It can propose, just as you.
The same type of democratic decision which decided the process of the jc "election" which you had no problem with. Call it "spontaneous democratic initiative", if you like. You had no problem with jfc's methodology, so please don't be a hypocrite. Let's just move forward, not back. Concentrate on the work ahead, not behind.
3) the verification of the panel Members must take place by the Provisional Membership Committee now forming before ANY of the mothions can be voted upon.
Please inform me by which democratic decision this was decided ?
There is not eleven possible votes because the eleven have not yet been verified by the Provisional Membership Committee.If you fail to do so I take the liberty of noting your opinion as such and thus being one of eleven possible votes.