Re: [atlarge-discuss] Verification Committee Methodologies

[DannyYounger@cs.com]

Abel,

Respectfully, as you are the Panelist that has put forward motion #2003-1 to 
"appoint Joey Borda to chair a committee for the time of 6 months, consisting 
of at least 5 but no more then 7 members for the sole purpose of verification 
of; 
Panel-members, Panel-replacement members, Committee-Chairs, Committee-members 
and other (semi-)official atlarge members", I am commenting on your choice of 
Mr. Borda to lead this effort.  I do not share your view that he is the one 
individual most suited to lead this initiative.

We all know that close to 90% of the people nominated never once made a 
single contribution to the discussion list.  As these people doubtless are not even 
subscribed to the discuss list, it is not reasonable to expect that they knew 
of the request of the Verification Committee to submit identity 
documentation.  Additional efforts should have been made by this Committee if they really 
wanted to know about these candidates; they should not have relied solely upon 
the submission of documents -- in my view, that is a reflection of poor 
judgement, and the Chair of this Committee should be one that has demonstrated a 
greater understanding of the elements involved in a verification process.

If I were to recommend a person for the job, it would probably be Walter 
Schmidt.


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: atlarge-discuss-unsubscribe@lists.fitug.de
For additional commands, e-mail: atlarge-discuss-help@lists.fitug.de