[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
RE: [atlarge-discuss] Provional Membership Committee
Jeff,
Could you please indicate why you think that Andre and David have
"failed miserably" in their willingness to contribute ?
Kind regards
Abel
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Jeff Holt [mailto:jefftttt@txucom.net]
> Sent: 08 June 2003 02:22
> To: 'Ron Sherwood'; 'Joop Teernstra'
> Cc: 'Joey Borda **star*walker**'; 'Kristen Doyle'; 'Martha
> Gottlieb'; 'Joanna Lane'; 'A/S Mauro D. Ríos'; 'Micheal
> Sherrill'; 'Sotiris Sotiropoulos'; 'Jeff Williams'; 'Abel
> Wisman'; 'IAL'
> Subject: RE: [atlarge-discuss] Provional Membership Committee
>
>
> @Large, et al.....
>
> Having been constantly involved in the Provisional Mbrship
> Mtg. which took place beginning early today and lasting until
> some point this evening, I had to take leave this afternoon.
> Upon my return I see that some actions have been taken and my
> name has been used without my consent. I take exception to
> this "report" issued by Ron Sherwood precipitously during my absence.
>
> Three Panelists-elect have failed miserably to confirm both
> existence and willingness to contribute to this organization,
> and, in my opinion, should be immediately asked to step aside
> from the Panel-elect. These three are:
>
> Sebastian Klein
> Andre Rebentisch
> David Goldstein
>
> I also concur with the minority opinion in that these
> individuals have had more than sufficient time to respond,
> have failed to do so repeatedly, and should be removed from
> the Panel-elect without further delay.
>
> Sincerely,
>
> TTTT
> Jefftttt@txucom.net
> www.tejas-info-services.com
>
>
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Ron Sherwood [mailto:sherwood@islands.vi]
> Sent: Saturday, June 07, 2003 7:18 PM
> To: Joop Teernstra
> Cc: Joey Borda **star*walker**; Kristen Doyle; Martha
> Gottlieb; Jeff Holt; Joanna Lane; A/S Mauro D. Ríos; Micheal
> Sherrill; Ron Sherwood; Sotiris Sotiropoulos; Jeff Williams;
> Abel Wisman; IAL
> Subject: [atlarge-discuss] Provional Membership Committee
>
> Dear Joop:
>
> I do not know if the Panel has elected a Chairperson or not.
> I therefore send the following reort to you as the Panel
> member who earned the highest number of votes in the recent
> @Large election.
>
> Please find below the report of the Provisional Membership Committee.
>
> This committee was not authorized by your Panel due to the
> fact that no Panel was in place at the time members were
> asked to volunteer to look into allegations that non-persons
> (unverified Internet persona) may have been included as
> canndidates and elected to office.
>
> The committee udertook to use the 24 hour period from
> 00:00Zulu Saturday to 00:00Zulu Sunday to look into these
> allegations and to attempt to determine if the elected Panel
> members had complied with three conditions requested by some
> members. Those simple requirements were:
>
> 1) that the elected Panel member be a real person and
> verified as such.
> 2) that the elected Panel member declare her / his
> willingness to serve on the Panel for a time certain.
> 3) that the elected Panel member make hemself or herself
> known to the membership they are elected to serve by way of
> an introductory post to the atLarge-discuss list.
>
> Our report and addenda are copied below.
>
> Respectfully, Ron Sherwood
>
> We, the members of the Provisional Membership Committee wish
> to advise the elected Panel and our @Large membership that
> during the past 24 hours we have determined that:
>
> 1) All elected Panel members are real persons and not
> artificial persona. (With the exception of two members, which
> comments are set as addenda (i) and (ii) below.)
>
>
> 2) a number of elected Panelists have declined to respond to
> members requests to introduce themselves to the membership on
> the atlarge-discuss list.
>
> 3) one elected Panelist, Sebastian Klein, has declined to
> confirm a willingness to work on the Panel for a time certain.
>
> 4) one Panel member,Sebastian Klein, has not responded to any
> email requests and has failed to post to any of this
> organization's fora. It is a possibility that Sebastian
> Klein is on vacation or incommunicado for some other reason,
> but we find it unreasonable that this Panelist has not asked
> to be excused from attending meetings of the Panel or posting
> on the atLarge-discuss list.
>
> 5) It is our recommendation to the Panel that:
>
> a) All unknown Panelists be required to introduce themselves
> to the membership on the atLarge-discuss list. (With the
> exception of one member
> which comment is set as addendum (iii) below.)
>
> b) Sebastian Klein be contacted and advised that his failure
> to attend three consecutive meetings or his failure to vote
> on three consecutive motions will lead to his automatic
> resignation from the Panel. (With the exception of one member
> which comment is set as addendum (iv) below.)
>
> c) if, for any reason, Sebastian Klein (or any other
> Panelist) resigns from the Panel, The next highest,
> qualified, vote-getter should be asked to join the Panel as a
> replacement.
>
> Addendum (i) Sotiris Sotiropoulos dissented from that
> consensus with the following notation: "No. No. No. We have
> established nothing of the kind. I cannot agree." Addendum
> (ii) Micheal Sherril dissented from the consensus with the
> following notation: "No, we have not established that
> statement for certain" Addendum (iii) Micheal Sherril
> dissented from the consensus with the following notation: "If
> they have not introduced themselves to the atLarge discuss
> list by this
> deadline this is a moot point. Recommend the boot, instead.
> They have already
> been asked several times to do this."
> Addendum (iv) Micheal Sherril dissented from the consensus
> with the following notation: "Same as above. Klein has
> missed the deadline. Recommend the boot, instead.
>
> Eleven members volunteered to work on this committee, nine
> members participated.
>
> The nine participants are:
> Joey Borda
> Jeff Holt
> Kristen Doyle
> Martha Gotlieb
> Joanna Lane
> Micheal Sherril
> Sotiris Sotiropoulos
> Abel Wisman
> Ron Sherwood.
>
>
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: atlarge-discuss-unsubscribe@lists.fitug.de
> For additional commands, e-mail: atlarge-discuss-help@lists.fitug.de
>
>
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: atlarge-discuss-unsubscribe@lists.fitug.de
For additional commands, e-mail: atlarge-discuss-help@lists.fitug.de