[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
[FYI] eBay not liable for bootlegged content
- To: email@example.com
- Subject: [FYI] eBay not liable for bootlegged content
- From: "jan.meyer" <firstname.lastname@example.org>
- Date: Fri, 10 Nov 2000 17:37:50 +0100
- Comment: This message comes from the debate mailing list.
- Reply-To: email@example.com
- Sender: firstname.lastname@example.org
eBay not liable for bootlegged content
A judge has ruled that online auctioneer eBay cannot be sued for
allowing people to sell bootlegged audio recordings on its Web site.
In a ruling late Tuesday, Superior Court Judge Stuart Pollak in
San Francisco County dismissed a lawsuit brought by a Grateful
Dead fan who sought to stop sales of illegal concert recordings
of the band.
"The suit argued that no legitimate brick-and-mortar auction house
or no legitimate brick-and-mortar record store could sell infringing
sound recordings to the extent that these are being sold on eBay and
get away with it," said Charles Perkins, the lawyer for plaintiff
The litigation did not focus on copyright infringement, as has the
Napster case. In that suit, the recording industry is suing the
song-swapping service in federal court for allegedly contributing
to copyright infringement by allowing millions of people to download
copyright music over the Internet for free.
In dismissing the suit, Pollak said he based his ruling on
the Communications Decency Act, which forbids computer service
providers for being punished for the speech of others.
"Plaintiff's attempt to impose responsibility on eBay as the seller
of items auctioned over its service is no different from the
attempts that have been made to hold computer service providers liable
as distributors rather than publishers of defamatory or pornographic
materials," Pollak wrote.
Courts have found that America Online, for example, was immune
from a suit brought by a mother who discovered pornographic
pictures of her young boy offered for sale online.
eBay attorney Jay Monahan said the ruling allows it "to continue
to operate our business and not fear facing liability at every turn."
He said the San Jose, Calif.-based company regularly pulls postings
from its site upon receiving complaints from copyright or trademark
holders of licensed music, software, movies, clothing and other goods.
Perkins said he is considering an appeal.
"We are trying to hold eBay responsible for its auctioning conduct,
not for the speech of somebody else," he said.