RE: [atlarge-discuss] POLLING COMMITTEE: mail sent to all the members

["Hugh Blair" <hblair@hotfootmail.com>]

> -----Original Message-----
> From: Jkhan
> 
> Jefsey, Please find my five ballot questions to follow below:
> 
> Question 1.
> What processes, management, organizational goals, lead you to 
> believe that your ideals are better than that of ICANN ?

This not the kind of question that can be asked on a ballot. No
matter how members answer there won't be a way to compile a
consensus view from their writings.

> Question 2.
> Which of the following comprises "WHO" IcannatLarge should represent:
> A.  Individual Domain Registrants
> B. Individual & Bulk Domain Registrants
> C. Bulk Domain Registrants
> D. Bulk Domain Registrants & Corporate Registrars
> E. Individual, Bulk Domain Registrants & Corporate Registrars

What Joanna said...

> Question 3.
> Do you favor a two year Cooling-Off Period* for former panel, 
> executive, and representative members of :
> ICANN, DNSO, IDNO, NSO, ICANN, ITU, WTO, WIPO, IETF, ISOC, IOD, etc..
> [* A ban from participating and lobbying in current Forums.]

Asking this on the ballot will be too late. If the members want
a cooling-off period it needs to be defined before nominations
start.

> Question 4.
> Do you think Icanatlarge.ORG and Icanatlarge.COM should be 
> separated and
> allowed to develop individually under separate houses?

This is not a valid question. No member should have the ability
and none have the right to tell Joop what he can and can't
do with his .com site. Unless he turned the domain over to
the .org web committee, when formed, he has the right to go
his own way.

> Question 5.
> Which one of the following is most closely related to the reason you
> participate in Icannatlarge:
> A. Individual Domain Registrants Rights
> B. Bulk Registrants Rights
> C. Industrial Lobby (Internet Telecommunications, Registrars 
> and Corps.)
> D. Governmental Affiliate (US, DoC, UN, EU, ccTDL-Country)
> E. Icann Member (Member of  Icann structure)
> F. Democracy Study (Foundation, Grant related work)
> G. Human Rights Study (Foundation, Grant related work)

This question might pass muster, but it's still a bad one.
If used, it would need be multiple choice, allowing the voter
to pick more than one option.

Nice try, no banana.

Hugh


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: atlarge-discuss-unsubscribe@lists.fitug.de
For additional commands, e-mail: atlarge-discuss-help@lists.fitug.de