Re: [icann-eu] Re: [ICANN-EU] ccTLDs to ask for BoD seats?

["Roberto Gaetano" <roberto_gaetano@hotmail.com>]

Jefsey,

>Roberto,
>I do not really understand you. You seem to defend/accept options you 
>dislike
>and which - i do hope - will never happen.

Sorry if it was unclear.
I try it again in few words.

If we have multiple roots, either they are coordinated (which is equivalent 
to have just one root with the algebrical union of the TLDs), or they are 
uncoordinated (opening the door to different Registries for the same TLD in 
different roots, and therefore uncertainity on where do you land when you 
type an url).

What I was saying is that the very moment you open the door to alternate 
roots outside ICANN's authority you allow the proliferation of "wild roots". 
You may "hope" that it will never happen, but there's no mechanism to stop 
it.

Anyway, the statement from Sabine Dolderer (see Alex' message) seems to 
confirm my feeling, i.e. that the ccTLDs do not really want to go to an 
alternate root system.
Maybe this is because they too, as you say for me, "do not have yet fully 
understood the way alt.root works" ;>)

Regards
Roberto


_____________________________________________________________________________________
Get more from the Web.  FREE MSN Explorer download : http://explorer.msn.com