[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

*To*: <atlarge-discuss@lists.fitug.de>*Subject*: [atlarge-discuss] REPORT ON ELECTION AND RESULTS - with the BALLOT*From*: "Hugh Blair" <hblair@hotfootmail.com>*Date*: Sun, 1 Jun 2003 00:52:49 -0400*Delivered-to*: mailing list atlarge-discuss@lists.fitug.de*Importance*: Normal*List-help*: <mailto:atlarge-discuss-help@lists.fitug.de>*List-post*: <mailto:atlarge-discuss@lists.fitug.de>*List-subscribe*: <mailto:atlarge-discuss-subscribe@lists.fitug.de>*List-unsubscribe*: <mailto:atlarge-discuss-unsubscribe@lists.fitug.de>*Mailing-list*: contact atlarge-discuss-help@lists.fitug.de; run by ezmlm

I'd like to pass on my personal thanks to the hard workers that managed this last weeks vote. Great job. Here's another way of looking at the voting - in the form of the ballot as it went out. Enjoy, Hugh > BALLOT ===================================================== > Panel election. Please "X" mark the candidates you support. > The 11 most supported ones will be elected. > In case of a resignation the next in line will be elected. > > =>01 7018637cj "X" [22] Asaad Alnajjar > > =>02 7018637cj "X" [44] Thierry Amoussougbo > > =>03 7018637cj "X" [59] Hugh Blair > > =>04 7018637cj "X" [67] Daniel Chirita > > =>05 7018637cj "X" [41] Bob Crawford > > =>06 7018637cj "X" [20] Kristen Doyle > > =>07 7018637cj "X" [71] David Goldstein > > =>08 7018637cj "X" [46] James Graham > > =>09 7018637cj "X" [46] Catherine Hughes > > =>10 7018637cj "X" [30] William Jones > > =>11 7018637cj "X" [68] Sebastian Klein > > =>12 7018637cj "X" [44] Curtis M Kularski > > =>13 7018637cj "X" [59] Gilbert Lumantao > > =>14 7018637cj "X" [59] Ivonne Valeria Muņoz Torres > > =>15 7018637cj "X" [39] Pierre Ouedraogo > > =>16 7018637cj "X" [46] Dominic Pinto > > =>17 7018637cj "X" [35] Mark Poole > > =>18 7018637cj "X" [61] Andre Rebentisch > > =>19 7018637cj "X" [48] Mauro Demian Rios > > =>20 7018637cj "X" [47] Jonathan Robin > > =>21 7018637cj "X" [22] Maniam S > > =>22 7018637cj "X" [25] Paustinus Siburian > > =>23 7018637cj "X" [51] Sotiris Sotiropoulos > > =>24 7018637cj "X" [100] Joop Teernstra > > =>25 7018637cj "X" [63] Daniel Tobias > > =>26 7018637cj "X" [10] James Voorhees > > =>27 7018637cj "X" [61] Abel Wisman > > QUESTIONNAIRE ============================================== > Here are elements to guide the Panel you elect. > Some themes call for you to chose, but please > answer everywhere all that _you_ think apply. > > > 1. an "@large" is [Choose one only] a Member of : > =>30 7018637cj 43(Y) - 11(N) the ICANN community > =>31 7018637cj 29(Y) - 16(N) any global internet governance org. > or is: > =>32 7018637cj 11(Y) - 21(N) mainly a domain name registrant > =>33 7018637cj 29(Y) - 16(N) a concerned user > =>34 7018637cj 26(Y) - 17(N) a common Internet user > > > 2. you want our organization to be: > [Choose one only] > =>35 7018637cj 24(Y) - 22(N) centralized > =>36 7018637cj 27(Y) - 16(N) central federal umbrella > =>37 7018637cj 54(Y) - 16(N) an alliance of @large organizations > > > 3. our membership is diverse - should we > [Answer all that apply] > =>38 7018637cj 52(Y) - 17(N) have a single organization > =>39 7018637cj 34(Y) - 11(N) unit member organizations > =>40 7018637cj 54(Y) - 10(N) have national members associations > =>41 7018637cj 46(Y) - 9(N) have specialized member organizations > =>42 7018637cj 13(Y) - 24(N) have parties > =>43 7018637cj 45(Y) - 13(N) have lists in different languages > =>44 7018637cj 38(Y) - 16(N) have an at-large site ring? > =>45 7018637cj 62(Y) - 7(N) have an at-large spokeman? > > > 4. we elect a Panel, should it mostly be a: > [Choose one only] > =>46 7018637cj 54(Y) - 13(N) decision structure > =>47 7018637cj 55(Y) - 7(N) a catalyst using motions and MoUs > > > 5. such a Panel should: > [Choose one only] > =>48 7018637cj 25(Y) - 19(N) be a "do-it-all" Panel > =>49 7018637cj 50(Y) - 15(N) administer specialized committees > =>50 7018637cj 41(Y) - 13(N) liaise with responsible committees > > > 6. the web site is important to our image, should it be: > [Answer all that apply] > =>51 7018637cj 59(Y) - 10(N) controled by the Panel > =>52 7018637cj 38(Y) - 15(N) independently managed by news pros > =>53 7018637cj 78(Y) - 5(N) include committee controlled subsites > > > 7. if we have committees should they: > [Answer all that apply] > =>54 7018637cj 45(Y) - 16(N) be chosen by the Panel > =>55 7018637cj 24(Y) - 19(N) be self selected > =>56 7018637cj 62(Y) - 9(N) be elected by the Members > =>57 7018637cj 51(Y) - 7(N) completed by open working groups > =>58 7018637cj 61(Y) - 3(N) organize an open deddicated maillist > > > 8. please indicate the committees areas of responsibility: > [Answer all that apply] > =>59 7018637cj 76(Y) - 8(N) membership > =>60 7018637cj 73(Y) - 6(N) constitution (incorporation, charter) > =>61 7018637cj 65(Y) - 8(N) polling > =>62 7018637cj 54(Y) - 9(N) executive (ext.relations, positions) > =>63 7018637cj 59(Y) - 5(N) finance > =>64 7018637cj 62(Y) - 9(N) website > =>65 7018637cj 37(Y) - 15(N) management of xxx.atlarge.ws sub-DNs > =>66 7018637cj 62(Y) - 5(N) press and public relations > =>67 7018637cj 55(Y) - 9(N) legal > =>68 7018637cj 34(Y) - 14(N) mailing list sergeant at arms > =>69 7018637cj 34(Y) - 11(N) ID control > =>70 7018637cj 53(Y) - 10(N) World Summit on Information Society > =>71 7018637cj 40(Y) - 10(N) user systems technology > > > 9. after committees and structure are established > [Choose one only] > =>72 7018637cj 20(Y) - 11(N) the Panel should be reelected > =>73 7018637cj 80(Y) - 6(N) should maintain stability for one year > [Choose one only] > =>74 7018637cj 49(Y) - 10(N) next Panel should count 11 Members > =>75 7018637cj 17(Y) - 11(N) next Panel should count 9 Members > =>76 7018637cj 17(Y) - 8(N) next Panel should count 7 Members > =>77 7018637cj 7(Y) - 13(N) next Panel should count 5 Members > > > 10. some organizational best practices > [Answer all that apply] > =>78 7018637cj 69(Y) - 5(N) we need a committee coordination list > =>79 7018637cj 39(Y) - 11(N) only watchdogs cannot be a candidate > =>80 7018637cj 57(Y) - 10(N) Polling Officers can be reelected > =>81 7018637cj 54(Y) - 23(N) Self Nominations are permitted > > > 11. we have to organize our democracy. Should we have: > [Answer all that apply] > =>82 7018637cj 65(Y) - 6(N) the WGs open to all and proposing > =>83 7018637cj 57(Y) - 6(N) committees elected and documenting > =>84 7018637cj 80(Y) - 1(N) major motions voted by members > =>85 7018637cj 60(Y) - 5(N) the Panel arbitrating conflicts > =>86 7018637cj 53(Y) - 15(N) an on-going monthly questionnaire > > > 12. our votes or monthly questionnaire will concern: > [Answer all that apply] > =>87 7018637cj 61(Y) - 6(N) elections > =>88 7018637cj 70(Y) - 4(N) votes on motions > =>89 7018637cj 73(Y) - 4(N) straw polls on maters of interest > =>90 7018637cj 64(Y) - 10(N) answers to influence the net industry > > > 13. the votes should be announced by email permitting: > [Answer all that apply] > =>91 7018637cj 79(Y) - 6(N) to click and vote (online) > =>92 7018637cj 63(Y) - 11(N) to mark and reply (offline) > =>93 7018637cj 73(Y) - 4(N) to access decision documenting links > =>94 7018637cj 82(Y) - 7(N) reminders should be sent > > > 14. relations with external entities - should we have: > [Answer all that apply] > =>95 7018637cj 40(Y) - 14(N) a WG per type of external relations > =>96 7018637cj 79(Y) - 6(N) relations with ICANN > =>97 7018637cj 54(Y) - 7(N) presence in the ICANN's RALO process > =>98 7018637cj 66(Y) - 3(N) relations with ccTLDs > =>99 7018637cj 59(Y) - 3(N) relations with community SLDs > =>A0 7018637cj 44(Y) - 7(N) an interface with the GAC > =>A1 7018637cj 50(Y) - 8(N) an interface with ITU > > > 15. to protect the ownership of our list, web site, DN. we > need to incorporate. Should we: > [Answer all that apply] > =>A2 7018637cj 49(Y) - 8(N) look for more than a shell structure > =>A3 7018637cj 45(Y) - 10(N) consider the tax exemption aspects > =>A4 7018637cj 13(Y) - 28(N) chose USA for tax exemption > =>A5 7018637cj 30(Y) - 16(N) chose France no tax no paperwork > =>A6 7018637cj 56(Y) - 10(N) run a comparative questionnaire > > > 16. we need some organization culture > [Answer all that apply] > =>A7 7018637cj 49(Y) - 9(N) resignations: next in line takes over > =>A8 7018637cj 35(Y) - 12(N) next in line: maximum 2/3 of the list > =>A9 7018637cj 59(Y) - 11(N) quorum: 2/3 of the committee member > =>B0 7018637cj 40(Y) - 9(N) committee: one second calls a vote > =>B1 7018637cj 41(Y) - 8(N) membership: ten seconds call a vote > =>B2 7018637cj 34(Y) - 18(N) WG: only members may participate > =>B3 7018637cj 68(Y) - 3(N) Members: must be identified persons > > > 17. as an @large member do you want to be involved in WG on: > [Answer all that apply] > =>B4 7018637cj 49(Y) - 8(N) DN registrant rights protection > =>B5 7018637cj 54(Y) - 9(N) privacy protection > =>B6 7018637cj 47(Y) - 9(N) e-environment human rights > =>B7 7018637cj 47(Y) - 12(N) digital divide > =>B8 7018637cj 22(Y) - 20(N) kid protection > =>B9 7018637cj 22(Y) - 18(N) wi-fi right protection > =>C0 7018637cj 22(Y) - 17(N) community/specialized SLD interests > =>C1 7018637cj 24(Y) - 17(N) small business constituency > =>C2 7018637cj 13(Y) - 21(N) Uniname (http://uniname.org) > =>C3 7018637cj 34(Y) - 12(N) internationalized domain names > =>C4 7018637cj 32(Y) - 12(N) multilingual domain names > =>C5 7018637cj 32(Y) - 13(N) IPv6 > =>C6 7018637cj 10(Y) - 19(N) RIRs > =>C7 7018637cj 30(Y) - 16(N) new generation networks > =>C8 7018637cj 19(Y) - 16(N) use of languages in governance orgs. > =>C9 7018637cj 33(Y) - 15(N) user technical interests protection > =>D0 7018637cj 36(Y) - 11(N) local communities outreach and action > =>D1 7018637cj 47(Y) - 13(N) new types of Internet usage > =>D2 7018637cj 18(Y) - 21(N) atlarge.ws sub-namespace management > =>D3 7018637cj 13(Y) - 22(N) atlarge.ws sub-namespace servicing > =>D4 7018637cj 39(Y) - 10(N) DNS evolution > =>D5 7018637cj 25(Y) - 16(N) an ITU WG on the Internet > =>D6 7018637cj 33(Y) - 15(N) World Submit on Information Society > =>D7 7018637cj 25(Y) - 20(N) Web Site management > =>D8 7018637cj 29(Y) - 18(N) @large public relations > =>D9 7018637cj 29(Y) - 16(N) @large political lobbying actions > > =========================================================== --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: atlarge-discuss-unsubscribe@lists.fitug.de For additional commands, e-mail: atlarge-discuss-help@lists.fitug.de

**Follow-Ups**:**RE: [atlarge-discuss] REPORT ON ELECTION AND RESULTS - with the BALLOT***From:*"Hugh Blair" <hblair@hotfootmail.com>

- Prev by Date:
**RE: [atlarge-discuss] Bylaws Discussion** - Next by Date:
**Re: [atlarge-discuss] REPROT ON ELECTION AND RESULTS** - Previous by thread:
**Re: [atlarge-discuss] Bylaws Discussion - Regarding moderation and membership** - Next by thread:
**RE: [atlarge-discuss] REPORT ON ELECTION AND RESULTS - with the BALLOT** - Index(es):