[atlarge-discuss] RE: Yet another result -- please verify your votes.

["Abel Wisman" <abel@able-towers.com>]

I must admit that indeed I did not check the number of votes per ballot,
good thinking!

Having checked the data below (wuick, visual) I can see the changes and
the correctness of the "overvotes".

This and Jefsey's file should be at most differing in the overvote
section (if he like me forgot this) and easily reconsilable. I suggest
that a statement will be made shortly by both outgoing panel and
watchdogs that this is in their opinion the correct outcome of the
election.

Kind regards

Abel



> -----Original Message-----
> From: Thomas Roessler [mailto:roessler@does-not-exist.org] 
> Sent: 02 June 2003 10:24
> To: Abel Wisman
> Cc: 'Atlarge Discuss List'
> Subject: Yet another result -- please verify your votes.
> 
> 
> On 2003-06-02 00:26:14 +0100, Abel Wisman wrote:
> 
> > Please do your own visual or coded count, I can easily have made 
> > errors, though I believe I was somehow thorough.
> 
> There were both overvoted (and thus invalid) ballots, and duplicates
> -- and some pathological cases in which people put "|" or "~" 
> between the brackets (invalid), or put quote characters 
> around their "X" (valid).
> 
> Taking that into account, I end up with the following result:
> 
>  1	24	Joop Teernstra                          	  89
>  2	07	David Goldstein                         	  63
>  3	11	Sebastian Klein                         	  57
>  4	04	Daniel  Chirita                         	  55
>  5	27	Abel Wisman                             	  55
>  6	25	Daniel Tobias                           	  54
>  7	18	Andre Rebentisch                        	  53
>  8	14	Ivonne Valeria Muņoz Torres             	  49
>  9	03	Hugh Blair                              	  47
> 10	13	Gilbert Lumantao                        	  46
> 11	23	Sotiris Sotiropoulos                    	  43
> 12	20	Jonathan Robin                          	  41
> 13	19	Mauro Demian Rios                       	  39
> 14	08	James Graham                            	  38
> 15	09	Catherine Hughes                        	  35
> 16	16	Dominic Pinto                           	  35
> 17	02	Thierry Amoussougbo                     	  35
> 18	12	Curtis M Kularski                       	  34
> 19	05	Bob Crawford                            	  33
> 20	15	Pierre Ouedraogo                        	  31
> 21	17	Mark Poole                              	  26
> 22	10	William Jones                           	  21
> 23	22	Paustinus Siburian                      	  17
> 24	01	Asaad Alnajjar                          	  17
> 25	06	Kristen Doyle                           	  15
> 26	21	Maniam S                                	  15
> 27	26	James Voorhees                          	   5
> 
> Details don't get past the list's size limit, and are 
> available from 
<http://log.does-not-exist.org/files/yet-another-result.txt> and
<http://log.does-not-exist.org/files/duplicates.txt>.

yet-another-result.txt is organized in a way which should make it easily
possible for individual participants to verify that the votes they cast
were properly counted.  I'd strongly recommend that you do precisely
that, and raise any issues you may have NOW, so we can get closure on
these results.

The perl script I used to do the analysis is available from
<http://log.does-not-exist.org/files/votecount.pl>.

votecount.pl reads Jefsey's ATLARGE.WTC from standard input, so this
result depends on the integrity of that file.  Any errors introduced
when translating e-mail messages into lines in ATLARGE.WTC are, thus,
propagated into this result.

The list of names of the voters who participated is available from
Jefsey's ATLARGE.VTR.

Regards,
-- 
Thomas Roessler				<roessler@does-not-exist.org>



---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: atlarge-discuss-unsubscribe@lists.fitug.de
For additional commands, e-mail: atlarge-discuss-help@lists.fitug.de