Re: [ICANN-EU] thanx for the fish & lets start the work

[Alf Hansen <aha@uninett.no>]

Hi,

What is importan are the CHARTERS for new lists. Andy, do you have the
charters ready for the new lists you have proposed?

Best regards,
Alf H


Geza Giedke wrote:
> 
> Andy Mueller-Maguhn writes:
> > icann-debate@lists.ccc.de
> > (subscribe with: icann-debate-subscribe@lists.ccc.de)
> >
> > is thought as an open forum of internet-users & at-large
> > members for discussion of icann- & related discussions
> 
> My first thought: what do we need another list for? Isn't
> icann-europe@fitug.de enough? In which respect would
> icann-debate@lists.ccc.de differ from icann-europe@fitug.de?
> One discussion list is IMHO better than two unless there are clear
> distictions as to what is discussed in either list.
> 
> But then: icann-europe@fitug.de has been largely a european affair -
> but as I see it there is only one topic that is (was) really
> euro-specific: the European @Large director.
> Now that the election is over, most questions will concern all regions
> alike.
> Wouldn't it therefore be better to have some global forum in which all
> the discussions that are not specific to a region are held?  There is
> no need to feel ourselves bound to the artificial separation
> introduced by ICANN. Is the not-region-specific traffic here willing
> to move to some global list?
> 
> Could/Should icann-debate@lists.ccc.de try to become this global list?
> 
> any comments?
> 
> regards
>  Geza
> 
>